I’m posting this list by my friend Bob because I think it is brilliant, and because I don’t have a top ten movie list for 2004 (I’m not sure if I even saw ten movies in 2004). I’ve only seen two of the movies on this list, but the rest have been added to my Netflix queue. Thanks, Bob.
#10 Being Julia
I actually felt that Annette Bening had left Warren Beatty to go live in this movie. And who wouldn’t? It would have been great to be roaming around the theater while Julia rehearsed her lines. And she knew her lines. Of the other characters in “Being Julia” only Julia knew that it was crucial to know our lines whether we were off stage or on stage. For Julia, all the world was a stage. Of course, I’m also a sucker for these period pieces, not to mention the great character performances by Jeremy Irons and Dustin Hoffman. And all originated from a story or novella by Somerset Maugham.
#9 Sideways
Four relatively ordinary people are given some great dialogue. I was thrilled to be taken along on this trip through wine country and to have a short introduction in their course of wine metaphors. Like many, I felt very uncomfortable going in for dinner after he made that comment about “merlot”. Hell, I always order merlot. Actually, since that movie, I’ve tried to break out with a cabernet sauvignon but I still lack confidence in how it’s pronounced. And, of course, confidence seemed to be one of the themes of this movie. We have all been in those places where we sure wished we felt more at home whether it’s ordering wine or engaging in ordinary conversation.
#8 Kill Bill Volume II
Whereas Kill Bill Volume I (which was in my last year’s top ten list) was simply Uma and Quentin on the vengeance trail, Volume II felt so much more deliberate. Both of these movies had the feeling of myth for me. The film got so much attention because of the use of violence to develop character and plot but, to me, this was the traditional story of the bond of mother and daughter which I’m really into these days. It may be sacrilege to say that I thought this was a feminist film but so much revolved around the intuitive gifts of the female characters. And I loved Bill’s soliloquy on Superman versus Batman and superheroes in our culture in general.
#7 Million Dollar Baby
You could almost smell that gym and you knew the toilets would never really get clean. Unlike other movies, this was not a place that I would want to be. Although we get a few small hints about the past of these three people, we will never really get to know a lot about them. And they don’t need to know much about each other either. They have honed into a loyalty for each other where all other questions are meaningless. Clint Eastwood tells Hilary Swank that he’ll never leave her but I could have heard any of these people say that line to any of the other three. So, we simply watch this unfold and, like critics have said, it does take us somewhere totally different. It’s a great story and I would like to read those boxing strategies for living.
#6 The Aviator
When I order the Jumbo popcorn as well as the Jumbo Diet Coke and watch a three hour movie with never even a thought of going to the bathroom, my body is telling me that I’ve seen a great film. To me,this was the 2004 salute to classic Hollywood-the way pictures used to be made. Martin Scorcese is great in showing us the story. I loved the scene where he went from caressing Ava Gardner’s body to caressing the side of the airplane. But then this whole movie was a very tactile experience which Scorcese is the best at giving us. In focusing on the smallest details, Scorcese gives us a classic and epic Hollywood movie.
#5 Finding Neverland
I never knew the story behind the creation of Peter Pan. And, quite frankly, I had never really thought about it. And that’s the first reason for giving this movie top-ten status. Damn it, art is not created in a vacuum and we do not experience it in a vacuum and I’m glad to have had this movie remind me of this. I’m not sure how to describe the feeling I had here but it was all so…tender. And if you ever needed a quick life lesson about holding on and letting go, this is the movie to go to.
#4 Love Song for Bobby Long
With John Travolta and Scarlet Johanson, I’m amazed that this film has not received more attention. Bobby Long (John Travolta) and his protege stay in a state of near or not-so-near inebriation living in a shack on the outskirts of New Orleans (we never see any part of that city) and their only possessions of value are the lines of literature that each remembers from a former life. Scarlet Johanson is the catalyst here and all lives will change. This film also includes a great performance by Dane Rhodes, a former Poetry Alive! performer.
#3 Ray
Because Jamie Foxx got so much acclaim for playing Ray Charles, I had avoided going because I got the feeling that this was one of those movies with his great performance and some great music and little else. Was I wrong! His performance deserves all of the accolades but this movie is about a lot more that Ray Charles. Throughout we have the look of the period. As a teenager in an all-white high school, I can remember the way teachers and parents (not mine, thankfully) responded to white kids dancing to music by black artists. I also remember a parent pulling the plug on a record player at a local (all white) swimming pool because of the music. The Ray Charles story presented so many of the major themes of my generation that it becomes much more than one man’s story. Unlike Being Julia or Sideways where I fantasized myself being there, in this movie I was there for it all.
#2 Hotel Rwanda
The Holocaust shaped many of the ways we describe the levels of inhumanity in our modern world. Usually, it is presented along with “we can never let this happen again.” Of course, it does continue to happen all over the world. This story is one such example taking place just a little over a decade ago. One of the great lines in this movie has a journalist giving the response of most people in the world to the butchery taking place in Rwanda. He said people would read about it or see a story on TV and say “How terrible!” and then go on about whatever they were going to do that day. But this film doesn’t spend lots of time showing us a variety of atrocities but simply uses them as a backdrop to show us what we too “could” do. The hotel manager here played by Don Cheadle is really no hero kind of guy. I had the impression that his greatest strength was catering to and sucking up to the wealthy European patrons of the hotel. During this film, he discovers the other strengths that may have always been there but never had to be called on. His transformation as told through Don Cheadle’s great performance is the essence of this film. This film is a reminder that we each have those same strengths. We simply need to get out the way and let them emerge when injustices, whether small or large, occur around us.
#1 Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
This movie has been my best since I first saw it with Larry Smith last spring. Of course, any movie whose title comes from a poem will have an edge with me. And this small line is not at the beginning or at the end but almost in the middle of Alexander Pope’s poem “Eloisa to Abelard”. I wish I could have been one of those people who instantly identified the line, its source and its significance. Alas, I was not. I had last read the poem over 30 years ago. I still think Pope is a great writer and I still remember lots of his couplets as many of us do but I’m confound if I can ever remember where the couplet could actually be found. So, I’m impressed that someone not only finds it but builds a screenplay and movie around that same theme. For me, this movie really begins the moment when Jim Carrey decides that he does not want to go through with the operation to obliterate his memory and knows how important it is to hold onto all even the smallest fragment because all of those “fragments” make us who we are. Ask anyone reaching the age where forgetfulness happens with ever-increasing frequency and they will tell you the importance of all of those fragments. Well, of course, I did go back and reread Pope’s poem and found buried in it what I feel is an appropriate review of what I feel this film did. You have to substitute “film” or “movies” for the word “letters” but it works for me.
Heav’n first taught letters for some wretch’s aid,
Some banish’d lover, or some captive maid;
They live, they speak, they breathe what love inspires,
Warm from the soul, and faithful to its fires…